Monday, April 13, 2009

Busy Spots of Knoxville in 1921

artist: Joseph F. McCamish

I ran across this at work yesterday and thought it was pretty sweet. (Click on the image to view a larger version of it) I thought it would be interesting if someone did a 2009 rendition. Notice the Market House that used to be in the center of Market Square and the trolleys on Gay and Union. I wish I could have seen it all like this.

17 comments:

AT said...

weird, but Hope Bros Jewelers is in the wrong location! Unless they moved into a different location, they opened Hope Bros Jewelers where Sapphire now lies. Eventually bought by Kimballs in the 30's.

The Modern Gal said...

It's interesting to see the Market Square area without the TVA buildings in the way. In most cities that serve as the county seat, you'd probably find the courthouse where the Market House is. I wonder why Knoxville was different.

max. said...

i like the "riveria photo plays" and the "farragut coffee room"

The Pol said...

I find it interesting that Coffe and Chocolate moved into a bulding that used to be "Quality Breads and Cakes".

The more things change...

Pianoman said...

A 2009 version of this would have parking garages on about half of the map. It's sad that people were so short sighted and tore down so many of these great buildings and replaced them with parking garages. Downtown would be so much greater now if there were more old buildings.

The Modern Gal said...

Pianoman, I agree that it's a shame any great old building is torn down, but where would you propose people park? I wish we could say Knoxville didn't need the parking garages, but they're vital to bringing people downtown -- and we obviously still don't have appropriate parking (see posts about 100 block of Gay Street).

Just playing a bit of devil's advocate.

Pianoman said...

It's not just parking garages that claimed the land from old buildings, like all the buildings along Wall Ave. are now home to TVA's buildings. We replaced great human-scale buildings with buildings that don't fit that bill.

As for parking, there are ways to get people into downtown without replacing what people like about downtown with parking garages. If Knoxville had a decent transit system, or useful bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure, etc, then there wouldn't be as much need to provide for the automobile.

Knoxville has alot going for it, but, like so many other cities, it jumped on board with city planning ideas of yesteryear that catered to the automobile and not the people.

Robert said...

wow. this image just made my day

Nate D. said...

B, I sent this image to a local dignitary who might be interested in purchasing a copy. Can you tell me how they might get ahold of one?

Anonymous said...

You can buy a copy of the original (not the 1981 trace-over copy) from http://reevesmaps.com/knoxville.htm.

Wayne said...

To AT: Hope Bros started in a location near the Krutch Park extension on the other side of Gay St, if memory serves me -- Jack Neely wrote about it when we were replacing the clock that Kimballs somehow felt they were intitled to....

Wayne said...

Another interesting bit of trivia ... the buildings on the 400 Blk of Gay listed as Newcomers and Cullens, were two sides of what is now the Phoenix. When we were renovating it, we found an old document that listed it's name as the 'phoenix' when built in 1899 after the great Gay St fire of 1897. After 'our' fire in 1999, we decided it was much more appropriate to rechristen it as 'the Phoenix' than to leave it as 'the Fowler Buidling.'

ck said...

There's a copy of this hanging in Mast General Store in the back. Found it so fascinating that I ended up looking at it for twenty minutes, looking like the creepy guy hanging out by the bathrooms.

Like many cities, it seems like Knoxville shot itself in the foot with 1960s style urban planning. The TVA towers and the City County Building are two prime examples of mega buildings that don't fit in with the scale of the city. As far as parking garages go- i think you can intelligently integrate them into city blocks, "filling in the donut hole" that most blocks have while keeping the street front filled with shops and residences, e.g. the block between central and state st. would be perfect. Just keep garages off the streetscape, or else you end up with dead blocks like Clinch near the YWCA.

I think the automobile and the pedestrian can be equally catered to, but it has to be a thoughtful, fine-grained approach to city design.

B said...

does anyone know what the significance of 1921 is?

Wax Sophocletus said...

CK: It is interesting, though, that both TVA and City County Building are Bruce McCarty designs. Your comment specifically relates to the scale of the buildings vs. the city as a whole, but it's interesting to note what I'm sure you're aware of - that McCarty designed specifically with an intent to create efficient community-focused, functional spaces. Even if your contention is that these buildings aren't successful, it seems that the planning failure was at least well-intentioned.

ck said...

wax: Funny thing is, I'm a fan of Bruce's. His small scale projects are awesome. But he was a product of his time: little to no context recognition, especially to urban areas. He seemed to love trying to create interior public spaces, but the "extension" of Market street in the C&C building is tenuous at best, and the TVA plaza is more of an urban wall intead of continuing Market Square's space. With one notable exception of his (I spent 5 years in it), his experiments at urban connection are largely failures. A brilliant architect, but a poor (well intended) urban planner.

dong dong23 said...

michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online clearances
abercrombie & fitch
louis vuitton handbags
adidas uk
louboutin pas cher
hollister kids
jordan concords
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet
nike roshe flyknit
jordans for sale
burberry outlet
fitflops
louis vuitton handbags
kate spade
hollister clothing
oakley sunglasses
louis vuitton outlet
toms shoes
insanity workout
longchamp handbags
kevin durant shoes 8
cheap jordan shoes
adidas outlet
louis vuitton
vans shoes outlet
gucci outlet
michael kors uk
nike air max 90
oakley outlet
adidas trainers
michael kors outlet
toms outlet
toms shoes
oakley sunglasses wholesale
michael kors bags
rolex watches
oakley sunglasses
hollister clothing
20166.14wengdongdong